Noelle

Aliza Vellani

Tech Elf Jojo

Alvina August

Jessie

Amitai Marmorstein

Tech Elf Robrob

Andy Nez

Mall Santa

Angela Moore

Shelter Worker

Anna Kendrick

Noelle Kringle

Anna Van Hooft

Elf Mary

Anthony Konechny

Elf Ted

Ariana Nica

Young Evelyn

Arran Henn

News Anchor

Ash Lee

Tonya's Father

Bill Hader

Nick Kringle

Billy Eichner

Gabriel Kringle

Billy Griffith

Elder Elf Billy

Brendan Taylor

Electronics Santa

Brian Cook

Colorado Kyle (uncredited)

Burgess Jenkins

Dan

Cara Mantella

Bus Driver

Chad Riley

Cop

Chelah Horsdal

Shelley Sussman

Clyde Lawrence

Elf Band #1

Craig March

Desk Sergeant

Dakota Guppy

Emma (uncredited)

Darcey Johnson

Arguing Man #1

Diana Maria Riva

Helen Rojas

Edwin Perez

Elf Chris

Gary Sekhon

Tech Elf Maxwell

Glen Gordon

Young Nick (uncredited)

Gracie Lawrence

Elf Carol

Jackie Blackmore

Clara Torres

Jagen Johnson

Elf Bop Beep

Jason Antoon

Omar

Jay Brazeau

Santa

Jesse Filkow

Homeless Son

Jon Kohler

New York Father

Julie Hagerty

Mrs. Kringle

Keith Dallas

Arguing Man #2

Kelly Metzger

Homeless Mother

Kingsley Ben-Adir

Jake Hapman

Lauren Halperin

Yoga Pants Customer

Lissa Neptuno

Evelyn's Mom

Maceo Smedley

Alex

Michael Delleva

Santa's Helper #2

Michael Gross

Elder Elf Abe

Oakley Bull

Young Noelle

Olson Lloyd

Santa's Helper #4 (as Chris Olson)

Owen Vaccaro

Young Nick

Ron Funches

Elf Mortimer

Sean Amsing

Elf Serge

Shauna Johannesen

Tonya's Mom

Shaylee Mansfield

Michelle

Shirley MacLaine

Elf Polly

Simon Chin

Elf Flobo

Taylor Bedford

Teenage Noelle

Thomas Cadrot

Homeless Father

Tyler McConachie

Angry Father

Viola Abley

Tonya

Vivian Lanko

Phone Woman

William Valenzuela

Matt Bautista (uncredited)